Taxonomic troubles in the Hemorrhois genus in Morocco

by & David Donaire Barroso.

In 2001 were recognized the genera Hemorrhois, Hierophis and Platyceps for some of the species previously assigned to Coluber (Schätti & Utiger, 2001; Schätti et al. 2001).

Four species are nowadays recognized in the genus Hemorrhois Boie, 1826: Hemorrhois hippocrepis (Linneo, 1758), Hemorrhois algirus (Jan, 1863), Hemorrhois nummifer (Reuss, 1834) and Hemorrhois ravergieri (Ménétries, 1832). These snakes are known for their colour pattern variability. The eastern species (H. nummifer and H. ravergieri) can even have designs that mimics the designs of the vipers of their same habitat. In other species is possible the change of the coloration with the age (H. algirus; Arnold & Burton, 1997; Baha el Din, 2006).

Only two species are known to occur in Morocco: H. algirus and H. hippocrepis (Bons & Geniez 1996) and the Maghreb.

H. hippocrepis is a large, thin and strong snake with big eyes, smooth scales and beautiful design based in rounded marks and a typical horseshoe mark in the head. It´s range covers the Iberian Peninsula, Morocco, Tunisia and some islands where it has been probably introduced recently (Sardinia, Balearic islands, etc…). It is one of the most common snakes in Morocco and occurs in the areas with Mediterranean clima north of the high Atlas chain, the Souss Valley reaching the south Atlantic coast until 20 Km north of Tan-tan (Bons & Geniez, 1996; Leon Vigara, 2012) and it has been recently found in Tendrara (B. Rebollo Fernandez & G. Martinez del Marmol, unpublished).

Hemorrhois hippocrepis
Hemorrhois hippocrepis. Casablanca (Morocco). Photo: © Gabri Mtnez.
Habitat of Hemorrhois hippocrepis
Hemorrhois hippocrepis. Habitat in Casablanca (Morocco). Photo: © Gabri Mtnez.

H. algirus is smaller and thiner than H. hippocrepis. It occurs in Morocco, Western Sahara, Mauritania, Algeria, Tunisia, Lybia, Egypt and Malta. In Morocco and Western Sahara is represented by the subspecies intermedius Werner, 1929 (Geniez et al., 2004), characterizated by a design of transversal bars along the body and horseshoe mark on the head following the original description of Werner (1929) but also by individuals with rounded blotches and horseshoe mark and grey-black headed individuals (Bons & Geniez, 1996). It occurs in a restricted distribution in Morocco limited to the Saharan zones (Bons & Geniez, 1996).

Hemorrhois algirus algirus
Hemorrhois algirus algirus, adult. Tunisia. Photo: © Tomas Mazuch.
Hemorrhois algirus algirus
Hemorrhois algirus algirus, subadult. Tunisia. Photo: © Tomas Mazuch.
Hemorrhois algirus intermedius
Hemorrhois algirus intermedius. Guelmim (Morocco). Photo: © Philippe Geniez.

Although the specific rank of Hemorrhois algirus and Hemorrhois hippocrepis has been ascertained (Schatti & Utiger, 2001; Nagy et al., 2004; Carranza et al., 2006; Wuster et al., 2007), the number of samples used is very low (Schatti & Utiger used samples from Rabat, Agadir and “Morocco” for hippocrepis and a Tunisian sample for algirus; Nagy et al. used samples of Tantan plage for algirus and a spanish sample for hippocrepis; Carranza et al. used just one algirus sample from Tunisia and many hippocrepis samples but all of them from north of the Atlas Chain so no “intermediate” individuals were compared to “pure” algirus or hippocrepis and Wuster et als samples has no origin known), the distribution of both species it is not totally clear in contact areas between both species. Bons & Geniez (1996) mentioned the difficulty to identify some individuals from the Anti Atlas chain in Morocco.

Hemorrhois sp. Hemorrhois sp.
Hemorrhois sp. with a grey coloration and with an absent horseshoe mark, pale dorsal circled marks, 25 rows of dorsal scales, in one side of the head the eye contact with a supralabial scale and in the other side there is a scale row between eye and supralabial scales (found by B. Rebollo Fernandez & G. Martinez del Marmol). Igherm (Morocco). Photos: © Gabri Mtnez.

Along the Atlantic coast of south Morocco, from Tiznit to Tan-Tan some ecological particularities allow that snakes of different biogeographycal origins occur in sympatry: tropical-sahelian snakes (Boaedon fuliginosus, Dasypeltis sahelensis, Bitis arietans, Naja haje), Mediterranean snakes (Macroprotodon brevis, Hemorrhois hippocrepis, Malpolon monspessulanus, Daboia mauritanica, Natrix maura) and Sindo-Saharan snakes (Cerastes cerastes, Cerastes vipera, Hemorrhois algirus, Rhagerhis moilensis, Spalerosophis dolichospilus, Psammophis schokari, Lytorhynchus diadema).


Contact area habitat. Between Guelmim and Tantan where H. hippocrepis meets H. algirus (Morocco). Photo: © Gabri Mtnez.

Moreover the extreme variability of design in both species in Morocco snakes makes indentification impossible based on current published keys alone and thus the relations between both species continue unclear (Bons, 1962; Bons & Geniez, 1996). Following Schleich et al. (1996) the main differences between both species are:

Table 1: Based in Schleich et al., 1996.

H. hippocrepis H. algirus
dorsal design rounded marks trasversal bars
horseshoe mark yes no
supralabial scales in contact with the eye Rarely Always 1 or 2
scales at midbody 25-29 23-25
ventral scales 214-258 209-237
subcaudal scales 72-109 83-110
anal scale usually is divided sometimes divided

However this information contrast with Werner (1929), Bons & Geniez (1996) and Geniez (2004) who include some Hemorrhois individuals with horseshoe mark in H. algirus. In contrast, Sochurek (1979) described these specimens as a subspecies of H. hippocrepis and suggested the possibility of being a full species or a hybrid between H. algirus and H. hippocrepis. In fact, the Schleich et al.’s description agrees with the eastern form, H. a. algirus, but not with the western form, H. a. intermedius (including “Coluber algirus villiersi” Bons, 1962; Geniez et al., 2004) which can exhibit a horshoe mark and rounded blotches on the dorsum, and has rarely a dark headed colouration. Even in the eastern form, has been published the possibility of 27 rows of dorsal scales at midbody (in most Malta specimens; Bons in Joger, 1997). Le Berre (1989) published that Coluber florulentus (includying H. algirus) has between 21-25 rows of dorsal scales at midbody, whereas to Gruber (1993) and Baha el Din (2006) all specimens of Hemorrhois algirus have 25 rows.

Hemorrhois algirus intermedius Hemorrhois algirus intermedius
Hemorrhois algirus intermedius (found by Raul Leon Vigara & Gabri Mtnez). Erfoud (Morocco). Photos: © Gabri Mtnez.

In Morocco (including Atlantic Sahara), western Algeria and Mauritania, some specimens can have a horseshoe-mark and can have a design of transverse bars (fitting with the Werner´s description of Coluber algirus intermedius). But it is also possible to find Hemorrhois sp. with unicolour head and unbranded horseshoe mark but with circular markings similar to H. hippocrepis. Schatti (1986) argued that the distinction of two subspecies of the Algerian whip snake (algirus and intermedius) is not conclusive because reliable characters are lacking.

About head pholidosis, it is common to find specimens with one side of the head with a supralabial scale in contact with the eye, but on the other side there is a row of scales between the eye and supralabials, in other cases on both head sides one or two supralabials scales are in contact with the eye, and sometimes on both sides of the head there is a row of scales between the eye and supralabials so the supralabial scales and their contact with the eyes is not a reliable characteristic to distinguish both species. Such individuals sometimes have a typical H. hippocrepis design but too pale and in the H. algirus typical habitat (pers. obs. in Tata, Igherm, Aouinet Lahna, Plage Blanche, Ouarzazate surroundings). Even in Tata we have seen individuals with 23 and 25 rows of mid-dorsal scales very close.

Hemorrhois sp. Hemorrhois sp.
Hemorrhois sp. with design H. hippocrepis but pallid coloration. Aouinet Lahna (Morocco). Photos: © Michel Aymerich.
Hemorrhois sp. Hemorrhois sp.
Hemorrhois sp. (found by J.P. Gonzalez de la Vega; L. Garcia-Cardenete; J.R. Fernandez Cardenete; V. Gabari Boa; F. Jimenez-Cazalla; J.A.M. Barnestein; J.A. Fernandez Carrasco & G. Martinez del Marmol). Tata (Morocco). Photos: © Gabri Mtnez.
Hemorrhois algirus
Hemorrhois algirus. Tata (Morocco). Photos: © Gabri Mtnez.

Hemorrhois sp. and H. algirus habitat. Tata (Morocco). Photo: © Gabri Mtnez.
Hemorrhois hippocrepis
Hemorrhois hippocrepis. Tendrara (Morocco). Photo: © Gabri Mtnez.

The extreme variability of individuals suggests some questions:

– Is it possible to group all these odd individuals in a subspecies of H. hippocrepis or H. algirus as it has been done historically with the subspecies “intermedius“?

– Would it be possible that in large areas of contact between both species hybridization has occurred and the so called subspecies “intermedius” is simply the product of a continuum hybridization zone of both Hemorrhois?

Against this latter hypothesis points out that following the distribution maps of Bons & Geniez (1996) most specimens of H. algirus with circular markings have been found outside the contact area with H. hippocrepis. It is precisely in the contact area with H. hippocrepis where more specimens were found with transversal bars design.

Although this could also be because most specimens with rounded blothches of the contact area could be automatically assigned to H. hippocrepis. But it seems very rare that Hemorrhois algirus has evolved with the horseshoe mark without any gene flow of H. hippocrepis although the presence of sympatric areas and “intermediate” individuals.

Mapa
Map. Red colour to Hemorrhois hippocrepis distribution area; Yellow spots to H. algirus with trasversal bars;
green spots to H. algirus with round marks & blue spots to black headed H. algirus (based in Bons & Geniez, 1996).
Hemorrhois algirus intermedius Hemorrhois algirus intermedius
Hemorrhois algirus intermedius. Tantan (Morocco). Photos: © Michel Aymerich.
Hemorrhois algirus intermedius Hemorrhois algirus intermedius
Hemorrhois algirus intermedius. Dakhla (WS). Photos: © Michel Geniez.
Hemorrhois algirus intermedius
Hemorrhois algirus intermedius. Habitat in Tantan (Morocco). Photos: © Gabri Mtnez.
Hemorrhois hippocrepis with strange design
Hemorrhois hippocrepis with strange design. Lakhsas (Morocco). Photos: © Gabri Mtnez.
Hemorrhois algirus intermedius
Hemorrhoishippocrepis”. Jebel Sirwa (Morocco). Photos: © Fernando Martinez-Freiria.

A genetic analysis with wide sampling (mostly “intermediate” and “strange” individuals) is madatory to clarify the taxonomical situation of this genus in Morocco.

Acknowledgements

Thanks to Philippe Geniez for his information and photos. To Mario Schweiger for his information and helping in the german translations. To Michel Aymerich, Tomas Mazuch and Fernando Martinez-Freiria, for their photos.

To cite this page:
Gabriel Martínez del Mármol Marín & David Donaire Barroso: Taxonomic troubles in the Hemorrhois genus in Morocco.
Published on October 03, 2012. Updated on October 18, 2012. Available from http://blog.moroccoherps.com/taxonomic-troubles-in-the-hemorrhois-genus-in-morocco/. Accessed December 11, 2017.

To cite www.moroccoherps.com as a whole:
Amphibians & Reptiles of Morocco and Western Sahara.
Available from www.moroccoherps.com. Accessed December 11, 2017.

Bibliography: